12 Kinds of Kindness - logo 12 Kinds of Kindness - handheld logo Eye

A 12-step experiment designed to open our hearts, eyes, and minds. Learn more
Image gallery
Step 10
Pay It Forward

We left wallets all over NYC with money and a note asking that the recipient do one kind thing with it. We also performed random acts of kindness on the streets.

Portrait

Step 10: Pay It Forward

Part 1: Unexpected Kindness

Last week, something happened that taught me how much a random act of kindness from a stranger could affect my day. 
I met up with my husband Zak to have dinner; we had decided to treat ourselves out to one of our favorite restaurants that night. We hadn’t been out to eat in weeks, as we’d been trying to get our spending down. As soon as we sat down, though, we immediately started venting about the major stressor in our life: our recent financial stress caused by our apartment renovation.
The list of everything that has gone wrong since starting this renovation process would be too long and boring to list here, but I’ll tell you, it has felt like hell. Aside from the enormous time suck, the process has left us with way more debt than we ever expected, and a year later, we still don’t have a home. We’ve been bouncing around various tiny, 300-square-foot sublets all year due to dozens of unexpected delays and ridiculous bureaucracies with city and co-op approval processes. People tell you when you start a renovation that it takes twice the time and twice the money you originally thought it would. But I think if you’re renovating in New York, you should double that estimate once more. 
Anyway, we were both feeling pretty defeated that night, whining about the financial stresses, how we wanted a real home with enough space to hang our clothes since we've been living out of a suitcase for a year, and how we couldn’t take this much longer. A couple next to us chimed in, saying that they had overheard we were renovating, and wondered if they could buy us dinner and a bottle of wine to celebrate our new home ownership.

Zak and I looked at each other in confusion: What did they want from us? I’ve never had a stranger offer to buy me a bottle of wine for no reason. The list of possibilities ran through my mind: Are they contractors looking for future business? Did they overhear that I’m a designer and need work done? Are they swingers, hitting on us?

We only accepted their offer after they insisted profusely. 
They told us they were from Canada and had dabbled in real estate development. They offered some valuable renovation advice, we exchanged some good conversation and few laughs. But as they talked, I kept waiting to hear what it is they wanted from us.
However, at the end of the dinner they took care of our entire bill in addition to the wine, and left. They wanted nothing. Zak and I were left bewildered at this random act of kindness. This sort of thing has never happened to me in New York, and I’ve lived here a decade. Maybe Canadians are kinder than New Yorkers?

Recent comments

Color & Code
Jan 10, 2017 21:51

I love this. You and Tim are all stars. You design work and your guerrilla campaigns in NYC are awesome. Also, regarding altruism, I also think that once you get "hooked" it is kind of selfish, but in the best way possible. We need more selfish, altruistic people in the world! <3

Lynn Hernandez
Jan 01, 2017 20:49

What goes around comes around. Right after the election, my husband and I were at HomeDepot. We spotted a man struggling to put two big pieces of plywood in his very small car. Having a truck, we offered to follow him home and deliver the materials. He was surprised and very appreciative and commented that if we all treated each other in this way, our country would be much better. That inspired me to continue with generosity in small ways. During Christmas shopping I gave a gift card with a small amount on it from a department store to someone shopping there as I was leaving. Lo and behold, yesterday while at a shoe store, someone gave me a coupon that she wasn't going to use. It ended up saving me $20 on my purchase. I found this sight through our Sunday paper's magazine section. There are some great ideas there too, and many I will try as students and staff return to school.

Whatever the reason, we were left feeling touched by their random act of kindness and inspired to pass on the generosity to someone else. Because, let’s be honest, my husband and I are insanely privileged to be able to afford a loan on a Manhattan apartment in the first place. There are many people who needed this nice free dinner and act of generosity more than we did. It helped put our troubles into perspective, and left us filled with gratitude. It made me realize how, too often, I find myself focusing on the negatives in my life instead of being thankful for how many things are going so well. 
So, the next time we were out to dinner, when I saw a couple fighting with each other, we told the waiter we’d pick up their check. We didn’t even go up and introduce ourselves or anything, but it felt great thinking that maybe we could have given them something to brighten up their stressful night.  It felt so good doing this that it made me think, what if we tried to do random acts of kindness like this on a larger scale? Would it inspire others to pay forward more random acts of kindness?
With this in mind, Tim and I have made “pay it forward” wallets which we will place all over the city.  

Part 2: Dropping Wallets

Dropping Wallets

We put money in wallets and dropped them all around NYC with a note inside.

So, Tim and I have been going all over the city dropping “pay it forward” wallets. We're going to continue to drop the wallets the week this post is out, so if you are in New York City, look out for one! Each has anywhere from $1 to $100 in cash inside, as well as a little “pay it forward” note. The notes suggested that kindness can be paid forward in many small ways — through a smile, by helping a stranger carry their bags — and that we'd hoped they’d pay it forward. We also included an email address for the recipient to use if they wanted to let us know what they did with it. 

Here are some of the responses below. (I've changed the names to respect the writers' privacy.)

These responses made me wonder what I'd do if I had found one of the wallets. What would you do if you found one? Would you pass it on, or keep they money for yourself?

I've felt conflicted about this project knowing that we’re doing these acts of kindness often with a camera following us and the intention to write about them here on this blog. Does it devalue what we’re doing? Will I continue to pay it forward after the project is finished? Though I am suspicious of my own motivations and intentions and have inner conflict about it, I have noticed what seems to be a real and genuine change in my behavior.

Even after the day we went out and dropped wallets for the project, I’ve continued doing these random acts spontaneously on my own. I’m more alert to those in need, and this whole kindness thing has truly felt addictive.

In fact, these good deeds have made me feel so great that I’ve started to wonder about the science behind it psychologically, and it turns out it's not just me who finds kindness to be addictive. Studies even show that kindness is contagious: a single act can lead to dozens more.

Sure, maybe its because I’ve realized how good it makes me feel to change someone's day or mood with small gestures, and maybe thats in part selfish; but the more I read about altruism, the more I've come to believe thats just human nature. We're programmed through evolution to be altruistic only as a self-motivation for survival in groups. In fact, many of the top philosophers have shown how every act of altruism has some selfish motive at its core, whether we're conscious about it or not. However being suspicious of my own intentions is not a good reason to not do good, either. I’ve had some amazing experiences this past month that I wouldn’t replace for the years of apathy prior. 

Based on these experiences, I made a little list of "Twelve Ways to Pay it Forward" list based on some of the things I've been doing this past month. I hope you'll pay it forward as well. 

Part 3: Twelve Ways to Pay it Forward

01. Leave pennies head face up: Most people feel lucky finding a penny with the head face up. For one dollar you can make 100 people feel awesome. 

02. Compliment someone: I know compliments are such a basic thing to do but for some reason I never do it, even though I know how much it makes my day when someone compliments me. So I complimented an old lady on her really oversized, funny hat. It wasn’t trendy or cool but it was weird and she seemed to be confident and just really own it. 

03. Don't snap at someone who is an asshole: A women with a unruly toddler cut in front of me in line to get lunch. Instead of snapping back at her like I might have in the past, I smiled gently and let her pass. She probably just had a bad day and my rudeness would only evoke more rudeness. 

04. Cover for someone who forgot their credit card: That same person who cut me in line went to pay but her credit card declined and she was on the verge of a melt down. So I told her to go ahead and not to worry, that I’d take care of it. It was amazing to witness her change in demeanor, her hard shell melted away and she spoke softly and warmly as she tried to refuse a few times and then eventually accepted, walking out the door with a faint smile.

Recent comments

Color & Code
Jan 10, 2017 21:51

I love this. You and Tim are all stars. You design work and your guerrilla campaigns in NYC are awesome. Also, regarding altruism, I also think that once you get "hooked" it is kind of selfish, but in the best way possible. We need more selfish, altruistic people in the world! <3

Lynn Hernandez
Jan 01, 2017 20:49

What goes around comes around. Right after the election, my husband and I were at HomeDepot. We spotted a man struggling to put two big pieces of plywood in his very small car. Having a truck, we offered to follow him home and deliver the materials. He was surprised and very appreciative and commented that if we all treated each other in this way, our country would be much better. That inspired me to continue with generosity in small ways. During Christmas shopping I gave a gift card with a small amount on it from a department store to someone shopping there as I was leaving. Lo and behold, yesterday while at a shoe store, someone gave me a coupon that she wasn't going to use. It ended up saving me $20 on my purchase. I found this sight through our Sunday paper's magazine section. There are some great ideas there too, and many I will try as students and staff return to school.

05. Give up a preferred seat to someone in need: A client bought me a business class seat and when I was standing in line I thought of that hilarious Louis CK skit, and I challenged myself to give my ticket away. When I saw a women who was sobbing while on the phone waiting in the economy line, I knew it had to be her. 

06. Write a positive review for a restaurant you like: I tend to only write reviews for places that give me horrible service. So I went down the list of my favorite go-to spots and wrote them a nice review on Yelp or Google.

07. Foster pets: This is something I did for years, when I found out that in NYC many local shelters need temporary foster homes on the weekends for puppies or kittens. During the weeks the animals are brought to pet stores in order to try to find them permanent homes. It was kind of a win/win because I love pets, but I work too much during the week to really care for them full-time.

08. Leave someone a huge tip: I was in line to get coffee and the person in front of me was rude to the barista. So I left her a 200% tip with a big smily face to hopefully brighten her day.

09. Give someone the benefit of the doubt: When people are an asshole towards me I tend to take it personally. However I also know I am not the center of the universe, and maybe that person had other reasons for their actions that I don't know about. Keeping this perspective is something I'm trying to do on a regular basis now.

10. Promote peoples work you admire: In the creative industry I've been saddened at how competitive people can be, and how much people shit-talk others. So this past year I've been trying to constantly promote people whose work I love or admire. A simple tweet, Instagram post, or even emailing people when you appreciate their work can go a long way. 

11. Offer to take a photo for tourists: I saw a bunch of tourists trying to take a photo and offered to take it for them. It made them happy and the world could use a few less selfies.

12. Call your mom: Read our step 9 post for more information about this one.

What are ways that you pay it forward? Would love to hear.

Part 4: Make Your Own Step

We'd love for you to participate in this 12-step journey with us. Step 10 is all about paying it forward. Pay for the person's coffee in front of you. Give up your basketball tickets to a friend. Give someone a compliment. Comment below or tag #12kindsofkindness on social media and let us know your stories. We'd love to hear them!

Feel free to use the artwork / quotes above to share your story on social, you can download them all on the 12 Kinds of Kindness Tumblr.

Back to top